FAQs on Arbitration Disputes in India

FAQs on Arbitration Disputes in India

What claimants and respondents need to know

Arbitration is now the default dispute resolution mechanism in Indian commercial contracts, and the law around it has moved faster in the last two years than in the decade before. In November 2024, a Constitution Bench in Central Organisation for Railway Electrification v. ECI-SPIC-SMO-MCML (JV) struck at one-sided appointment clauses. On  April  30th, 2025, another Constitution Bench in Gayatri Balasamy v. ISG Novasoft Technologies Ltd. [2025 INSC 605] held that courts have a limited power to modify arbitral awards. A draft Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Bill, 2024 is also awaiting Parliament.

As arbitration lawyers in Delhi, we are approached by claimants and respondents with similar questions almost every week. We have brought together answers to these frequently asked questions under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (“the Act”), as amended in 2015, 2019 and 2021, read with the latest rulings of the Supreme Court and the practice of the Delhi High Court. For a fuller walk through the statute itself, see our Working Guide to the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

8 Nov 2024

30 Apr 2025

Oct 2026  ·  NOW

Constitution Bench in CORE curbs unilateral appointment of arbitrators

Constitution Bench in Gayatri Balasamy allows limited modification of awards

1996 Act (as amended to 2021) governs; 2024 draft Bill not yet enacted

CONTENTS

Part A   The basics   (Q1–5)

Part B   The arbitration clause   (Q6–10)

Part C   Starting an arbitration   (Q11–15)

Part D   Urgent and interim relief   (Q16–18)

Part E   The award: challenge and enforcement   (Q19–23)

Part F   Practical questions in Delhi   (Q24–28)

Part G   Getting started   (Q29–31)

PART A   The basics

  • What is arbitration, and how is it different from going to court?

Arbitration is a private method of resolving disputes in which the parties agree to have one or more arbitrators decide the matter instead of a civil court. The decision, called an arbitral award, is binding and enforceable like a court decree.

The differences that matter commercially are choice and finality. Parties choose the arbitrator, the procedure, the language and the place. The grounds to challenge an award are deliberately narrow, so there is no full appeal on facts or merits as there would be from a trial court decree.

  • Which law governs arbitration in India?

The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, as amended in 2015, 2019 and 2021. Part I governs arbitrations seated in India. Part II governs the enforcement of foreign awards under the New York and Geneva Conventions. The draft Amendment Bill released in October 2024 has not been enacted, so none of its proposals are law yet (see Q24).

  • Can every kind of dispute be referred to arbitration?

No. Most commercial disputes are arbitrable: contracts, supply and distribution, construction, joint ventures, shareholder agreements, leases under the Transfer of Property Act, licensing and franchise. But the Supreme Court in Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading Corporation [(2021) 2 SCC 1] confirmed that some matters stay with courts and statutory forums:

  • Criminal offences and matters of a public or sovereign nature.
  • Personal and family matters: matrimonial, guardianship and testamentary disputes.
  • Insolvency and winding-up proceedings, which belong to the NCLT.
  • Tenancy disputes governed by special rent control laws.
  • Matters reserved for a special forum, such as consumer complaints: Emaar MGF Land Ltd. v. Aftab Singh [(2019) 12 SCC 751].
  • Can allegations of fraud be decided by an arbitrator?

Generally, yes. After Avitel Post Studioz Ltd. v. HSBC PI Holdings (Mauritius) Ltd. (2021) 4 SCC 713], a mere allegation of fraud does not oust arbitration. The dispute leaves the arbitral forum only if the fraud goes to the arbitration agreement itself, or has a public dimension, such as allegations of arbitrary or mala fide conduct by the State. A parallel criminal complaint for cheating does not, by itself, stop a civil arbitration on the same transaction (Conundrum on Cheating in India: Civil Wrong or Criminal Offence).

  • What if the other side is an MSME?

Where the supplier is a registered micro or small enterprise and the claim is for delayed payment, Section 18 of the MSMED Act, 2006 allows it to approach the MSE Facilitation Council. In Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd. v. Mahakali Foods (P) Ltd. [(2023) 6 SCC 401], the Supreme Court held that this statutory route prevails over a private arbitration clause. A buyer wanting to challenge an award made through the Council must first deposit 75% of the awarded amount under Section 19, which changes the economics of any challenge.

PART B   The arbitration clause

  • What makes an arbitration agreement valid?

Under Section 7, it must be in writing and show a clear intention to refer disputes to arbitration. It can be a clause in the main contract or a separate agreement. An exchange of letters, e-mails or other electronic communications recording the agreement is enough.

Vague wording is the most common problem we see. Clauses that say disputes “may” be referred to arbitration, or that leave the final decision to a company officer, are regularly fought over at the threshold, sometimes for years.

  • What is the difference between the “seat” and the “venue” of arbitration?

The seat is the legal home of the arbitration. It decides which courts supervise the proceedings and hear any challenge to the award. The venue is only the physical place where hearings happen. Since BGS SGS Soma JV v. NHPC Ltd. [(2020) 4 SCC 234], naming a place as the seat gives the courts of that place exclusive supervisory jurisdiction. A clause that says “venue: New Delhi” with nothing more invites an argument; one that says “the seat of arbitration shall be New Delhi” does not.

  • Our contract was not stamped properly. Is the arbitration clause dead?

No. In In re: Interplay between Arbitration Agreements under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 [2023 INSC 1066], a seven-judge bench held that an unstamped or insufficiently stamped agreement is not void. Stamping is a curable defect, not a ground for the court to refuse to appoint an arbitrator, and the objection is for the tribunal to examine. Pay the deficit duty when required, but do not let the issue delay invoking arbitration.

  • Can a company that never signed the contract be bound by the arbitration clause?

In the right facts, yes. The Constitution Bench in Cox and Kings Ltd. v. SAP India (P) Ltd. 2023 INSC 1051] accepted the “group of companies” doctrine. A non-signatory can be bound where its conduct in negotiating, performing or terminating the contract shows a mutual intention that it be a party. *ASF Buildtech (P) Ltd. v. Shapoorji Pallonji & Co. (P) Ltd.* (2025) confirmed that the arbitral tribunal itself can decide whether a non-signatory should be joined. Group structures no longer offer an easy exit from arbitration ([Investment Disputes Between Investors and Promoters).

  • Our clause lets the other party appoint the sole arbitrator. Is that allowed?

Not any more. The Supreme Court’s rulings have closed this door step by step:

  • Interested party cannot appoint: TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engineering Projects Ltd. [(2017) 8 SCC 377].
  • Nor nominate a sole arbitrator unilaterally: Perkins Eastman Architects DPC v. HSCC (India) Ltd. [(2020) 20 SCC 760].
  • Equal treatment in constituting the tribunal: CORE v. ECI-SPIC-SMO-MCML (JV) (2024), which applies to appointments made after 8 November 2024.

Separately, Section 12(5) read with the Seventh Schedule bars employees, consultants and others closely connected to a party from acting as arbitrator, unless both sides waive it in writing after the dispute arises. If your standard form contract still has a one-sided appointment clause, it should be redrafted now.

PART C   Starting an arbitration

  • How does an arbitration formally begin?

Under Section 21, arbitral proceedings commence on the date the respondent receives a request to refer the dispute to arbitration, the notice invoking arbitration. That date matters for limitation, so the notice should be sent by a method that proves delivery.

A well-drafted notice identifies the contract and the arbitration clause, summarises the dispute and the relief claimed, and proposes an arbitrator or calls on the other side to concur. Any pre-arbitration steps in the clause, such as negotiation for a fixed period, should be completed or demonstrably attempted first.

  • What is the limitation period for an arbitration claim?

The Limitation Act, 1963 applies to arbitrations through Section 43. For most contract claims, the period is three years from when the cause of action arose. A claim that would be time-barred in a civil suit is equally time-barred in arbitration. There is a separate clock for court applications: in Arif Azim Co. Ltd. v. Aptech Ltd. [2024 INSC 155], the Supreme Court held that a Section 11 petition must be filed within three years of the other side’s failure to appoint after a valid notice.

  • What if the other side does not agree to an arbitrator?

After 30 days, a party can apply under Section 11: before the High Court for a domestic arbitration, and before the Supreme Court for an international commercial arbitration. Many arbitration lawyers in Delhi file these before the Delhi High Court, which hears a heavy docket of Section 11 petitions and often refers matters to the Delhi International Arbitration Centre.

The court’s enquiry at this stage is narrow. After SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Krish Spinning [2024 INSC 532], the referral court looks only at whether an arbitration agreement exists. Questions such as accord and satisfaction, or whether claims are time-barred on the merits, are left to the tribunal.

  • The other side has filed a civil suit despite our arbitration clause. What can we do?

Apply under Section 8 to the court where the suit is pending, asking it to refer the parties to arbitration. The application must be filed no later than the date of your first statement on the substance of the dispute, with the original or a certified copy of the arbitration agreement. Filing a written statement on the merits without first seeking reference can be treated as a waiver of the right to arbitrate.

  • How long does an arbitration take in India?

For arbitrations seated in India, other than international commercial arbitrations, Section 23(4) and Section 29A set these outer limits:

Stage

Time limit

Pleadings (claim and defence)

Within 6 months of the tribunal receiving notice of its appointment

Award

Within 12 months from completion of pleadings

Extension by consent

Up to 6 further months

Further extension

Only by court order; arbitrator fees may be reduced for delay

Challenge to award (Section 34)

3 months from receipt of the award, plus up to 30 days on sufficient cause

In Rohan Builders (India) (P) Ltd. v. Berger Paints India Ltd. (2024), the Supreme Court held that an extension application can be filed even after the period has expired. In practice, a typical domestic commercial arbitration runs between 12 and 24 months.

PART D   Urgent and interim relief

  • Can we get urgent protection before the arbitration even starts?

Yes. Section 9 allows a party to approach the court for interim measures before, during, or after the arbitral proceedings until the award is enforced. Typical orders include:

  • Restraining the invocation or encashment of a bank guarantee.
  • Securing the amount in dispute or attaching assets.
  • Preserving goods, property or documents.
  • Injunctions against alienating shares or assets.

If the court grants relief before arbitration begins, the applicant must commence arbitration within 90 days, or within any period the court sets. For arbitration lawyers in Delhi, Section 9 petitions are among the most frequent filings, because speed at this stage often decides the commercial outcome.

  • Once the tribunal is constituted, can we still go to court for interim relief?

Ordinarily, no. Section 9(3) directs the court not to entertain an application once the tribunal is in place, unless the remedy before the tribunal is not efficacious. The application should then be made to the tribunal under Section 17. Since the 2015 amendment, a tribunal’s interim order is enforceable as if it were an order of the court.

  • Is emergency arbitration recognised in India?

Yes, within institutional rules. In Amazon.com NV Investment Holdings LLC v. Future Retail Ltd. [(2022) 1 SCC 209], the Supreme Court held that an emergency arbitrator’s order under the SIAC Rules is an order under Section 17(1) and is enforceable in India. It is available only if the parties chose institutional rules that provide for it, such as those of SIAC, ICC, MCIA or DIAC. The 2024 draft Bill proposes to write it into the Act, but that is not yet law.

PART E   The award: challenge and enforcement

  • Can an arbitral award be challenged? On what grounds?

Yes, but only by an application to set it aside under Section 34. It is not an appeal, and the court will not re-weigh evidence or substitute its view of the contract. The grounds are limited to:

  • Incapacity of a party, or an invalid arbitration agreement.
  • Lack of proper notice, or a party being unable to present its case.
  • The award dealing with matters beyond the scope of the reference.
  • An improperly constituted tribunal or a procedure contrary to the agreement.
  • A subject matter that is not arbitrable.
  • Public policy of India: fraud or corruption, contravention of the fundamental policy of Indian law, or conflict with the most basic notions of morality or justice.
  • Patent illegality appearing on the face of the award (domestic awards only).

Courts read these narrowly after Ssangyong Engineering & Construction Co. Ltd. v. NHAI [(2019) 15 SCC 131]. But the curative ruling in Delhi Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. v. Delhi Airport Metro Express (P) Ltd. (2024) shows that a perverse or unreasoned award remains vulnerable.

  • What is the deadline to challenge an award?

Three months from the date the party receives the signed award, or from the disposal of a correction request under Section 33. The court may condone a further delay of up to 30 days if sufficient cause is shown, and not a single day beyond that. Missing this window usually ends the challenge entirely, so the clock should be diarised the day the award arrives.

  • Can the court change the award instead of setting it aside?

In limited cases, yes. In Gayatri Balasamy v. ISG Novasoft Technologies Ltd. [2025 INSC 605], a five-judge Constitution Bench held by a 4:1 majority that courts may modify an award:

  • Severance: where the invalid part of the award can be separated from the valid part.
  • Obvious errors: clerical, computational or typographical errors apparent on the face of the record.
  • Post-award interest: adjustment in appropriate cases.
  • Article 142: by the Supreme Court alone, sparingly, to do complete justice.

The court still cannot revisit the merits. A party seeking a better result on the facts must show a ground for setting aside, not merely an error it disagrees with.

  • Does filing a challenge stop the award from being enforced?

No. Since the 2015 amendment, there is no automatic stay. The award-debtor must apply for a stay under Section 36(3), and for money awards the court usually grants it only on deposit of the awarded amount or adequate security. An unconditional stay is available only where the court is prima facie satisfied that the arbitration agreement or the award was induced by fraud or corruption.

Once the challenge period expires or the challenge fails, the award is enforced as a decree under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. An appeal against a Section 34 order lies under Section 37; where the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 applies, it must be filed within 60 days.

  • How is a foreign arbitral award enforced in India?

Under Part II of the Act. An award made in a New York Convention country notified by India as a reciprocating territory, including the UK, Singapore, the UAE and the US, is enforced through a petition before the High Court with jurisdiction over the assets. The court cannot set aside a foreign award; it can only refuse enforcement on the narrow grounds in Section 48. Once satisfied, the court treats the award as its own decree.

PART F   Practical questions in Delhi

  • Has the Arbitration (Amendment) Bill, 2024 become law?

Not at the time of writing. The Department of Legal Affairs released the draft on 18 October 2024 for public consultation, following the report of the T.K. Viswanathan expert committee of 7 February 2024. It has not been passed by Parliament. The draft proposes renaming the statute the Arbitration Act, 1996, defining the seat, recognising emergency arbitrators, enabling online hearings and introducing an appellate arbitral tribunal. Until enacted, every arbitration in India continues under the 1996 Act as amended up to 2021.

  • What happens to a pending arbitration if the other party goes into insolvency?

Once the NCLT admits the corporate debtor into the corporate insolvency resolution process, the moratorium under Section 14 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 bars the institution or continuation of proceedings against it, including arbitration. Claims must then be filed with the resolution professional. Proceedings initiated by the corporate debtor to recover money from others may continue. Timing a claim against a financially stressed counterparty is therefore a strategic question (Insolvency & Bankruptcy).

  • How much does arbitration cost, and who pays?

Costs depend on the claim value, the number of arbitrators, the institution and the length of hearings. The main heads are arbitrator fees, institutional fees, counsel fees, venue and stenography charges, and expert costs. The Fourth Schedule sets a model fee scale for ad hoc arbitrators, and in ONGC Ltd. v. Afcons Gunanusa JV (2022) the Supreme Court held that a tribunal cannot unilaterally fix its own fees. Under Section 31A, the general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs.

  • Which court in Delhi hears arbitration matters?

It depends on the type of application and the value of the dispute:

Application

Forum

Section 11 appointment

Delhi High Court (domestic); Supreme Court (international commercial arbitration)

Section 9 / Section 34, domestic

Commercial Division of the Delhi High Court above ₹2 crore; district commercial courts below that

Section 9 / Section 34, international commercial arbitration seated in India

High Court, regardless of value

Enforcement of a foreign award

High Court with jurisdiction over the assets

Getting the forum wrong wastes weeks and, for Section 34, can cost a party its limitation window.

  • Which arbitral institutions are available in Delhi?

The two main ones are the Delhi International Arbitration Centre (DIAC), attached to the Delhi High Court, and the India International Arbitration Centre (IIAC), a statutory institution set up in 2019. Parties also frequently choose ICC, SIAC or MCIA rules while keeping New Delhi as the seat. Institutional arbitration brings fixed fee schedules, appointment mechanisms, a secretariat and emergency arbitrator provisions, and for high-value or cross-border disputes it is usually worth the administrative cost.

PART G   Getting started

  • What should a claimant do first?
  1. Read the arbitration clause closely: the seat, number of arbitrators, appointment method and any pre-arbitration steps.
  2. Check limitation for the claim, and diarise the three-year deadline.
  3. Preserve every document of the transaction: contract, correspondence, invoices, ledgers and e-mails.
  4. Consider a Section 9 petition at once if assets, guarantees or shares are at risk.
  5. Send a notice invoking arbitration by a method that proves delivery.
  • What should a respondent do on receiving a notice of arbitration?
  1. Respond within the time the clause allows; silence can lead to a Section 11 appointment without your input.
  2. Check the notice for jurisdiction, limitation and scope objections at the outset.
  3. Do not file a defence on the merits in any parallel civil suit before seeking reference under Section 8.
  4. Evaluate counter-claims early, since they must be raised before the same tribunal.
  5. If the other side has appointed its own sole arbitrator, object promptly under Section 12(5) and the CORE
  • Why you must have a lawyer in an arbitration dispute?

Arbitration is technical, deadline-driven and, after CORE and Gayatri Balasamy, changing quickly. Most of the outcome is shaped early: by the clause, the notice and the first interim application, long before any hearing on the merits. With the Delhi High Court carrying one of the heaviest arbitration dockets in the country, early advice from experienced arbitration lawyers in Delhi can make the difference between a quick, enforceable award and years of satellite litigation. More on our arbitration work is on our Litigation & Arbitration practice page, and you can reach us through Connect with us.

ADDITIONAL READINGS

  1. A Working Guide to the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996: https://equicorplegal.com/a-working-guide-to-the-arbitration-and-conciliation-act-1996/
  2. Investment Disputes Between Investors and Promoters Under the Companies Act, 2013: https://equicorplegal.com/investment-disputes-between-investors-and-promoters-under-the-companies-act-2013-a-corporate-lawyers-perspective/
  3. Shareholder Disputes in India: A Case Law Analysis: https://equicorplegal.com/shareholder-disputes-in-india-a-case-law-analysis/

DISCLAIMER

This article is for information purposes only and should not be taken as legal advice.

To know further details, clarification, assistance or any advice on arbitration disputes, whether commercial, contractual, infrastructure, investor and shareholder, interim relief, or challenge and enforcement of awards, you may connect with us at admin@equicorplegal.com / 08448824659 and visit www.equicorplegal.com

The law is stated as of October 14th, 2026.

Similar Posts